The Legal Framework of Background Screening Checks

Sadie . March 19, 2024

Background screening checks have become an essential part of the hiring process for many organizations. These checks involve investigating an individual’s criminal history, educational background, employment history, and other pertinent information. The purpose of background screening checks is to ensure employers make informed decisions when hiring new employees. This article will discuss the legal framework of background screening checks, including their importance, the legal requirements that employers must adhere to, and the best practices for conducting these checks.

Importance of Conducting Background Screening Checks

Background screening checks are crucial for several reasons. First and foremost, they help employers mitigate potential risks linked to hiring individuals who could jeopardize the workplace or the organization’s reputation. Through comprehensive background checks, employers can uncover any warning signs that might suggest a candidate is unsuitable for a specific role.

Secondly, background screening checks assist employers in confirming the accuracy of the information provided by candidates throughout the hiring process. This includes validating educational qualifications, employment history, and professional certifications. By doing so, employers can ensure that they recruit individuals possessing the requisite skills and qualifications for the job.

Furthermore, conducting background screening checks can also help protect an organization from potential liability. Suppose an employer fails to conduct reasonable background checks and hires an individual with a history of criminal activity or misconduct. In that case, they may be held legally responsible for any harm caused by that individual. Therefore, background screening checks provide a layer of protection for employers and minimize the risk of negligent hiring claims.

Legal Requirements for Background Screening Checks

Employers must know the legal requirements for background screening checks to ensure compliance and avoid legal issues. The FCRA is a primary law governing background checks. The FCRA sets forth specific guidelines and procedures that employers must follow when obtaining and using consumer reports, consumer reports, including background checks. According to the FCRA, employers must receive the candidate’s written consent before conducting a background check and furnish them with a copy of the report if adverse action is taken based on the information discovered.

Additionally, the EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) provides guidelines that employers must consider when conducting background checks to avoid discrimination. According to the EEOC, employers should only consider relevant information in the hiring process and not use background checks to discriminate against individuals based on protected characteristics like race, religion, color, sex, or national origin. Employers must ensure that their background screening policies and practices align with EEOC guidelines to prevent potential legal issues.

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Its Implications

The FCRA plays a significant role in regulating background screening checks. This federal law aims to promote the accuracy, fairness, and privacy of consumer information collected by consumer reporting agencies. Employers who use third-party background screening companies to conduct checks must comply with the FCRA’s requirements.

Under the FCRA, employers needed to follow specific procedures when obtaining and using consumer reports for employment purposes. These procedures include obtaining written consent from the candidate, providing the candidate with a copy of the report if adverse action is taken, and issuing pre-adverse and adverse action notices, which notify the candidate that their application may be rejected based on the information in their background check report.

Noncompliance with the FCRA can result in severe consequences, including legal action and financial penalties. Therefore, employers must familiarize themselves with the FCRA’s provisions and follow the necessary steps to comply with the law.

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) Guidelines for Background Checks

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission offers guidelines for employers to ensure that background checks are conducted relatively and non-discriminately. These guidelines aim to prevent discrimination against individuals based on their protected characteristics, like race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.

As per the EEOC, employers should consider the gravity and relevance of the offense, the time elapsed since the offense or completion of the sentence, and the nature of the job being sought when making employment decisions based on background check information. Employers must clearly understand and apply these guidelines consistently to avoid potential discrimination claims.

State-Specific Laws and Regulations for Background Screening Checks

In addition to federal laws such as the FCRA and EEOC guidelines, employers must also be aware of state-specific laws and regulations regarding background screening checks. Many states have their own rules that impose additional requirements and restrictions on employers conducting these checks.

For example, some states have “ban the box” laws restricting employers from asking about applicants’ criminal histories on job applications. Other states may have limitations on how far back employers can consider an applicant’s criminal record or may require employers to provide specific notices or disclosures to candidates. Employers must understand and comply with the particular laws and regulations of the states in which they operate to avoid legal consequences.

Compliance Challenges in Background Screening Checks

Complying with the legal framework surrounding background screening checks can take time for employers. One of the primary challenges is ensuring that the information obtained through these checks is accurate and up to date. Employers must work with reputable background screening companies that use reliable sources to gather information and maintain strict data protection measures.

Another challenge is maneuvering through the intricate federal, state, and local laws and regulations network. Employers must allocate time and resources to keep abreast of evolving regulations or new requirements. Noncompliance with these laws can lead to legal consequences and damage the organization’s reputation.

Moreover, employers must balance conducting thorough background checks and respecting candidates’ privacy rights. Background checks often involve accessing personal information, and employers must handle this information carefully and ensure that it is used solely for making informed hiring decisions.

Best Practices for Conducting Background Screening Checks

Employers should follow best practices when conducting background screening checks to ensure compliance and mitigate potential risks. Some of these best practices include:

  • Develop a clear and comprehensive background screening policy that details the types of checks to be conducted, the procedures to be followed, and the criteria for evaluating the results.
  • Before conducting background checks, obtain written consent from candidates and provide them with a copy of the report if adverse action is taken based on the findings.
  • Use reputable background screening companies that follow industry best practices and demonstrate a proven track record of accuracy and reliability.
  • Train hiring managers and Human Resource personnel on the legal requirements and best practices for conducting background checks to ensure consistent and compliant practices throughout the organization.
  • Regularly review and update background screening policies and procedures to ensure alignment with changes in laws and regulations.
  • Maintain strict data protection measures to ensure the security and confidentiality of candidates’ personal information.

By following these best practices, employers can reduce legal risks, ensure compliance with regulations, and make informed hiring decisions based on reliable and accurate information.

Benefits of Using a Reputable Background Screening Company

Employers can significantly benefit from using a reputable background screening company to conduct background checks. Some of the key benefits include:

  • Access to accurate and up-to-date information: Reputable background screening companies have access to reliable sources of information, ensuring that the results are accurate and up to date.
  • Compliance with legal requirements: Background screening companies are well-versed in the legal requirements surrounding background checks and can help employers ensure compliance with federal, state, and local laws.
  • Time and cost savings: Employers can save valuable time and resources by outsourcing background checks to a reputable company rather than conducting them in-house.
  • Expertise and experience: Background screening companies have the expertise and experience to conduct thorough and efficient background checks, reducing the risk of errors or omissions.
  • Protection against legal risks: By using a reputable background screening company, employers can minimize the risk of legal action and potential damages resulting from noncompliance or negligent hiring.


The legal framework surrounding background screening checks is complex and ever-evolving. Employers must be aware of the legal requirements and guidelines set forth by federal, state, and local laws to ensure compliance and minimize legal risks. By conducting thorough background screening checks, employers can make informed hiring decisions, mitigate potential risks, and protect their organization’s reputation.

Ready to streamline your background screening process and ensure compliance with legal requirements? Visit Vertical Identity today to discover how our reputable background screening services can help you make informed hiring decisions while minimizing legal risks. We’re here to support your hiring needs with accurate and up-to-date information, expert guidance on compliance, and efficient processes. Don’t let compliance challenges hold you back – take the first step towards reliable background screening with Vertical Identity.


With our simple 3-step process, you’ll be quickly and affordably screening in minutes!