Volunteer Background Checks for Trust & Retention

Sarah Hope . March 18, 2024

Volunteer Background Checks for Trust & Retention

Volunteers are the backbone of nonprofit organizations, schools, shelters, and community programs. But managing volunteers comes with responsibility โ€” especially when those volunteers interact with vulnerable populations, handle funds, or represent your brand.

This is where volunteer background checks become essential. They donโ€™t just protect your organization โ€” they reduce turnover, build community trust, and create a safer environment for everyone involved.


๐Ÿ” Why Volunteer Background Checks Matter

Many nonprofits are hesitant to require background screening, fearing it will scare away good people. But the truth is, volunteers appreciate structure and safety. A well-run screening process shows your program is organized, legitimate, and committed to safety.

Benefits of background checks include:

  • Protection from legal liability

  • Safer environments for children and vulnerable adults

  • Higher quality, long-term volunteers

  • Enhanced public trust and donor confidence

๐Ÿ“Ž Hereโ€™s why background checks are considered a best practice in volunteer management


๐Ÿ”„ How Background Checks Help Reduce Volunteer Turnover

When volunteers are properly screened, theyโ€™re more likely to:

  • Stay long-term

  • Show up consistently

  • Take their role seriously

Screening filters out those with red flags early โ€” reducing conflict, absenteeism, and the risk of disciplinary issues later. It also helps prevent burnout by ensuring your team is made up of trustworthy, committed individuals.


๐Ÿงพ What Types of Volunteer Background Checks Should You Run?

Here are some of the most common checks nonprofits use:

  • National Criminal Database Search: Reveals felony or misdemeanor convictions

  • Sex Offender Registry Checks: Especially important for volunteers who work with youth

  • Alias or Multi-Jurisdiction Checks: To uncover offenses under other names or in other states

  • Motor Vehicle Records: Ideal for drivers or transport volunteers

  • Reference Checks: To confirm prior volunteer experience or spot red flags

  • Social Security Verification: Helps verify identity

Not all checks are necessary for every role. Choose the right level based on your volunteer responsibilities.


๐Ÿ› ๏ธ Implementing Volunteer Checks: Tips for Nonprofits

Follow these best practices when adding background screening to your volunteer onboarding process:

  1. Create a clear policy and share it with all applicants

  2. Get written consent before screening

  3. Use a reputable screening provider that understands nonprofit needs

  4. Apply checks consistently across similar roles to avoid legal issues

  5. Train staff on how to interpret results and protect confidentiality

๐Ÿ”— Learn how we support organizations with easy, secure volunteer background checks


๐Ÿšง Common Challenges & How to Overcome Them

Concern: Itโ€™s too expensive
Solution: Screening is more affordable than litigation or public trust damage. Most checks start under $25.

Concern: It might scare off good volunteers
Solution: Present screening as a professional, safety-driven policy. People feel safer joining well-run programs.

Concern: Weโ€™re not sure how to stay compliant
Solution: Work with a provider like Vertical Identity to manage consent forms, FCRA compliance, and result delivery.


๐Ÿ’ผ Partner with Vertical Identity

We help nonprofits, churches, and community groups screen volunteers nationwide. With affordable pricing, fast turnaround, and bulk packages available โ€” we make it easy to stay compliant and protect what matters.

๐Ÿ“ Visit verticalidentity.com
๐Ÿ“ฑ Call us at (602) 899-1606
๐Ÿ”’ Safe, accurate, and FCRA-compliant volunteer background checks

faf6a1a9 72c2 4e24 aa5d 7227729b4135

 

VERTICAL IDENTITY MAKES THE BACKGROUND SCREENING
PROCESS EASY FOR OUR SMALL BUSINESS CUSTOMERS.

With our simple 3-step process, youโ€™ll be quickly and affordably screening in minutes!