Volunteer Background Checks: Best Practices for Nonprofit Organizations

Sadie . March 17, 2024

Volunteers play an essential role in the success of nonprofit organizations. They dedicate their time, skills, and passion to positively impact the community. However, nonprofit organizations need to prioritize the safety and well-being of the individuals they serve. This is where volunteer background checks come into play. By implementing effective background check practices, nonprofit organizations can ensure a secure environment for both volunteers and those they serve.

Why Volunteer Background Checks are Important for Nonprofit Organizations

Volunteer background checks are vital for nonprofit organizations as they serve several purposes. Firstly, they help identify any past criminal activities or red flags that could pose a risk to the organization or its beneficiaries. By conducting thorough background checks, nonprofits can mitigate the likelihood of placing individuals with a history of violence, theft, or abuse in positions of trust.

Secondly, volunteer background checks build trust and credibility within the community. When prospective volunteers and donors see that an organization takes the safety of its beneficiaries seriously, they are more likely to engage and support its mission. By implementing stringent background check practices, nonprofits can showcase their dedication to the welfare of their community.

Legal Considerations for Volunteer Background Checks

While volunteer background checks are essential, nonprofit organizations must also navigate legal considerations to ensure compliance. Familiarizing oneself with local, state, and federal laws regarding background checks and privacy rights is crucial. Nonprofits should seek guidance from legal professionals to formulate procedures and policies that follow these regulations.

Additionally, obtaining proper consent from volunteers before conducting background checks is important. This involves providing volunteers with a clear and concise explanation of why the background check is necessary, accompanied by obtaining their written consent. By following these legal considerations, nonprofit organizations can conduct background checks ethically and within the boundaries of the law.

Developing a Comprehensive Volunteer Screening Policy

Nonprofit organizations should develop a comprehensive volunteer screening policy to establish effective volunteer background check practices. This policy should outline the organization’s commitment to safety, the types of background checks required for different volunteer roles, and the process for conducting these checks.

The screening policy should also address how the organization will handle background check results, including the criteria for disqualifying volunteers based on their findings. It is essential to balance ensuring safety and giving individuals a fair chance to explain any discrepancies in their background check reports.

Identifying the Necessary Background Checks for Different Volunteer Roles

Different volunteer roles may require varying levels of background checks. For example, volunteers working directly with vulnerable populations, such as children or the elderly, may require more comprehensive checks, including fingerprinting and sex offender registry searches. On the other hand, volunteers involved in administrative or non-contact roles may require less extensive checks.

Nonprofit organizations should carefully evaluate the responsibilities and potential risks associated with each volunteer role to determine the appropriate level of background checks required. This ensures that volunteers are adequately screened based on the specific requirements of their roles, enhancing the safety and security of the organization and its beneficiaries.

Implementing a Consistent and Standardized Screening Process

Consistency and standardization are key when implementing volunteer background checks. Nonprofit organizations should establish a clear process for conducting and evaluating background checks, ensuring that every volunteer undergoes the same screening procedures.

This process should incorporate instructions for gathering volunteer information, choosing reliable background check providers, evaluating outcomes, and making informed decisions based on the findings. By implementing a consistent and standardized screening process, nonprofit organizations can minimize bias and ensure the volunteer selection process is fair.

Finding Reliable Background Check Providers for Nonprofits

Nonprofit organizations must work with reliable providers to conduct thorough and accurate background checks. It is essential to choose background check providers specializing in nonprofit screening with a proven track record of delivering reliable and comprehensive reports.

When selecting a provider, consider factors such as the depth of their background checks, the accuracy of their reports, their compliance with privacy regulations, and their customer service. It is also prudent to verify certifications or accreditations demonstrating their dedication to quality and ethical standards.

Educating Volunteers about the Background Check Process

Communication and Transparency are key when doing volunteer background checks. Nonprofit organizations should educate volunteers about the background check process, ensuring they understand these checks’ purpose, scope, and importance.

Volunteers should be provided with clear information on what information will be collected, how it will be used, and how their privacy will be protected. Additionally, organizations should establish channels for volunteers to ask questions or seek clarification regarding the background check process. By educating volunteers, organizations foster a sense of trust and collaboration, enhancing the overall volunteer experience.

Ongoing Monitoring and Re-screening of Volunteers

Background checks should not be a one-time event. Nonprofit organizations should implement ongoing monitoring and re-screening practices to ensure the continued safety of their beneficiaries. The circumstances and backgrounds of volunteers can change over time, emphasizing the need to stay vigilant and proactive in recognizing any possible risks.

Establish a process for periodic re-screening of volunteers, particularly those in long-term or high-risk roles. This can be done annually or as deemed necessary based on the organization’s policies and the nature of the volunteer work. Ongoing monitoring demonstrates a commitment to the continuous safety and well-being of the organization’s beneficiaries.

Ensuring Confidentiality and Compliance with Privacy Regulations

Volunteers should be given clear information regarding what data will be gathered, why it is collected, and the steps taken to protect their privacy. Establishing secure systems for storing and accessing background check reports is essential, ensuring that only authorized individuals can access this sensitive information.

Additionally, organizations should develop protocols for properly disposing of background check reports once they are no longer needed. By adhering to privacy regulations and ensuring confidentiality, nonprofits demonstrate their respect for volunteers’ privacy rights and maintain the trust of their stakeholders.


Volunteer background checks are vital to nonprofit organizations’ comprehensive risk management strategy. By implementing these best practices, nonprofits can create a safe and secure environment for their beneficiaries and volunteers. While the process may require careful planning, legal considerations, and ongoing monitoring, investing in volunteer background checks is invaluable in protecting the organization’s mission and those it serves. Safety should always be a top priority when engaging volunteers in nonprofit work.

Are you a nonprofit organization looking to enhance the safety and security of your volunteers and beneficiaries? Vertical Identity offers reliable and comprehensive background check services tailored specifically for nonprofits. Our dedicated team ensures thorough screenings while prioritizing privacy and compliance with legal regulations. Take the proactive step towards safeguarding your organization by partnering with Vertical Identity today. Visit our website to learn more about our services and get started!


With our simple 3-step process, you’ll be quickly and affordably screening in minutes!